I liked this. I think. It was a little odd in places but I think it ended well. There were several things that happened that I didn't really see coming like Madame being Rose's mother, Linden dying, Vaughn dying I kind of saw because how else would they escape him?. I was aggravated with Silas being brought to the mansion at the end. I mean, really, was that necessary? I think she should have brought Jared instead. He would have fit in nicely with Reed. And then she tries to put Silas and Cecily together at the very end? What was that? I really just don't know how I feel about this book. I don't know that I'll ever read it again but I'm not sorry I read it once. I guess that's the best way to sum it up.